Best10Mattress is supported by our readers. We may earn commission on purchases w/ our links.
New Mattress Is Too Firm

New Mattress Is Too Firm

Written by: Daniel Connell · Updated on: January 19, 2024

See Our #1 Researched Mattress in 2024

Rated best for comfort and hotel-feel

Get 450$ OFF Mattresses

Key Takeaways

You can tell if your newly purchased mattress is too firm.

There will be immediate pain in your sensitive pressure points (neck, shoulders, arms, back, and hips).

You may wake up tired and sore, toss and turn at night, or have trouble getting comfortable at night if your mattress is too firm.

All brand-new mattresses (spring, foam, and latex) need to be broken in.

After they are shipped from the factory, foams settle into their final positions after 2-3 weeks.

You can, however, take several steps to soften it.

• Settle Foams: Stand or crawl on top of your mattress. This should even out the foams. Do this every night for 60-120 seconds until you notice some 'settling' (2-3 weeks).
• Buy a Topper: Buy a Talalay latex topper is likely the preferred option before changing your mattress entirely (i.e. do not exchange it, rather pick a new brand).
• Return & Replace: If a topper doesn't work, your best bet is to buy a new mattress. This prevents you from wasting time and energy testing solutions that are unlikely to work while you continue to suffer from pain due to your firm mattress.

#1 Fix For Your 'Too Firm' New Mattress

In case your firm mattress is old and worn out, we recommend buying a new one. This is the most effective solution for a firm bed.

Consider a topper. That's only a temporary fix. Don't temporarily fix a problem you'll have to deal with soon. Replace your mattress as soon as possible.

According to our extensive analysis, we believe the Saatva Classic is the most popular mattress in America right now.

7 Signs Your New Mattress Is Too Firm

Your current mattress may be too firm if you have the following indicators:

1. You just bought it, so it needs time to settle in.
2. The mattress is old (which means it's broken in) and you still find it too firm (probably needs to be replaced).
3. You rotate it regularly but still find it too firm.
4. You have trouble falling asleep or getting comfortable at night.
5. You toss and turn and constantly wake up in the middle of the night.
6. You feel tired or sore when you wake up. Sleeping well did not leave you feeling refreshed.
7. Your sensitive pressure points cause you real pain (you should see your doctor as soon as possible).

A rotated mattress, much like rotated tires, typically wears more evenly and reduces indentions or support issues.

5 Real Solutions To Fix Your 'Too Firm' New Mattress

These 5 solutions will help you fix a new mattress that is too firm:

1. Rotate. Ensures that foams settle evenly.
2. Add a latex topper. This works very well. You can get a good Talalay for $200 on Amazon.
3. Check your support (you can replace it with a metal bunkie board).
4. Allow it to break in (if it's a new mattress)
5. Replace your mattress. If your mattress is over 5-7+ years old, it is likely better to just buy a new one.

What If I Can'T Afford To Replace My New Mattress With Another One?

If you can't afford a new mattress, that's not an issue.

This is why "buy now, pay later" programs exist.

Saatva Classic, for example, offers the option to pay in monthly payments (interest-free). Provided you're responsible, it's definitely worth it.

Buying a new mattress is the only option if nothing else works (which is likely to be the case).

Putting your health and wellness at risk is not an option.

How Can I Tell If My New Mattress Is Too Firm And What Can I Do About It?

If you're wondering if your new mattress is too firm, pay attention to how your body feels when you lie down. If you experience pressure points or discomfort in your hips, shoulders, or lower back, it may be too firm for you. Waking up stiff or sore can also be a sign that your mattress is too firm for your sleeping style.

To improve your sleep experience, consider adding a mattress topper designed to add softness and cushioning. Memory foam toppers offer extra support and pressure relief, while down or feather toppers add a plush layer of comfort. If you're hesitant to invest in a topper, break in your mattress by walking on it or sleeping on it for a few more nights to see if it becomes more comfortable over time.

Finding the right mattress is a personal decision based on individual preferences and needs. Try different options to find the one that works best for you. Many mattress companies offer sleep trials, allowing you to test out a mattress for a certain period of time before committing to it. Take advantage of these trials to ensure that you're getting the best possible sleep experience.

Additional Related Secondary Content:

About X

X is the Founder and Editor-in-Chief of NapLab.com. He has been featured in Fast Company, Reader's Digest, Business Insider, Realtor.com, Huffington Post, Washington Post, AskMen, and She Knows. X has personally tested over 268+ mattresses and hundreds of pillows, sheets, beds, and other sleep products.

See Our #1 Researched Mattress in 2024

Rated best for comfort and hotel-feel

Get 450$ OFF Mattresses

References

New Mattress Is Too Firm

Why you can trust Best 10 Mattress? We spend hours analyzing, compiling and fact-checking all up-to-date information online, so you can be sure you’re reading accurate and trustworthy information.

Best 10’s Verdict

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Suspendisse varius enim in eros elementum tristique. Duis cursus, mi quis viverra ornare.

Pros

  • rthrthfwew wef wefwefw wefwefwefwef wefwef
  • etgerg
  • rthrth
  • rhrtr

Cons

  • rthrth wefw ef wef wefwef wef wefwef wef
  • etgerg
  • rthrth
  • rhrtr

You can tell if your newly purchased mattress is too firm.

There will be immediate pain in your sensitive pressure points (neck, shoulders, arms, back, and hips).

You may wake up tired and sore, toss and turn at night, or have trouble getting comfortable at night if your mattress is too firm.

All brand-new mattresses (spring, foam, and latex) need to be broken in.

After they are shipped from the factory, foams settle into their final positions after 2-3 weeks.

You can, however, take several steps to soften it.

• Settle Foams: Stand or crawl on top of your mattress. This should even out the foams. Do this every night for 60-120 seconds until you notice some 'settling' (2-3 weeks).
• Buy a Topper: Buy a Talalay latex topper is likely the preferred option before changing your mattress entirely (i.e. do not exchange it, rather pick a new brand).
• Return & Replace: If a topper doesn't work, your best bet is to buy a new mattress. This prevents you from wasting time and energy testing solutions that are unlikely to work while you continue to suffer from pain due to your firm mattress.

#1 Fix For Your 'Too Firm' New Mattress

In case your firm mattress is old and worn out, we recommend buying a new one. This is the most effective solution for a firm bed.

Consider a topper. That's only a temporary fix. Don't temporarily fix a problem you'll have to deal with soon. Replace your mattress as soon as possible.

According to our extensive analysis, we believe the Saatva Classic is the most popular mattress in America right now.

7 Signs Your New Mattress Is Too Firm

Your current mattress may be too firm if you have the following indicators:

1. You just bought it, so it needs time to settle in.
2. The mattress is old (which means it's broken in) and you still find it too firm (probably needs to be replaced).
3. You rotate it regularly but still find it too firm.
4. You have trouble falling asleep or getting comfortable at night.
5. You toss and turn and constantly wake up in the middle of the night.
6. You feel tired or sore when you wake up. Sleeping well did not leave you feeling refreshed.
7. Your sensitive pressure points cause you real pain (you should see your doctor as soon as possible).

5 Real Solutions To Fix Your 'Too Firm' New Mattress

These 5 solutions will help you fix a new mattress that is too firm:

1. Rotate. Ensures that foams settle evenly.
2. Add a latex topper. This works very well. You can get a good Talalay for $200 on Amazon.
3. Check your support (you can replace it with a metal bunkie board).
4. Allow it to break in (if it's a new mattress)
5. Replace your mattress. If your mattress is over 5-7+ years old, it is likely better to just buy a new one.

What If I Can'T Afford To Replace My New Mattress With Another One?

If you can't afford a new mattress, that's not an issue.

This is why "buy now, pay later" programs exist.

Saatva Classic, for example, offers the option to pay in monthly payments (interest-free). Provided you're responsible, it's definitely worth it.

Buying a new mattress is the only option if nothing else works (which is likely to be the case).

Putting your health and wellness at risk is not an option.

How Can I Tell If My New Mattress Is Too Firm And What Can I Do About It?

If you're wondering if your new mattress is too firm, pay attention to how your body feels when you lie down. If you experience pressure points or discomfort in your hips, shoulders, or lower back, it may be too firm for you. Waking up stiff or sore can also be a sign that your mattress is too firm for your sleeping style.

To improve your sleep experience, consider adding a mattress topper designed to add softness and cushioning. Memory foam toppers offer extra support and pressure relief, while down or feather toppers add a plush layer of comfort. If you're hesitant to invest in a topper, break in your mattress by walking on it or sleeping on it for a few more nights to see if it becomes more comfortable over time.

Finding the right mattress is a personal decision based on individual preferences and needs. Try different options to find the one that works best for you. Many mattress companies offer sleep trials, allowing you to test out a mattress for a certain period of time before committing to it. Take advantage of these trials to ensure that you're getting the best possible sleep experience.